(i) Unilineal development
Nineteenth-century ethnologists were the initial anthropologists to take an interest in matrilineal kinship. Poring more than ethnographic definitions of individuals of the globe ton towards the Western-had written by the colonial authorities, explorers, missionaries, and later, anthropologists-they listed standard habits, discovering that some societies tracked origin patrilineally and you will comparatively fewer tracked ancestry matrilineally. Started by an appeal determined because of the Darwin’s recently blogged To your Source from Types , Tylor [13,14] and Morgan [step one,15] advised the common aspects of people community recommended one sequence out-of societal progression through which all ‘evolving’ communities advances, and therefore this new varying areas of peoples culture showed that societies move across this type of amounts from the more cost. It ‘unilineal evolution’ perspective entailed a ranking-purchased category out of communities, by which get across-cultural variations in societal and you can scientific complexity was in fact named symptoms ent (, pp. 3–18).
Following , Morgan grabbed these periods since a kick off point to own proposing five steps in the new successive development of your family. 500; ). During the a later stage, Morgan debated one good subsistence shift into ‘dinner forcibly acquired’ (, p. 501) do necessitate the formation of consanguineous teams at which emerged household, and you can, through the years, matriliny and you will matrilocal quarters, ultimately causing the formation of origin groups around a good gynecocracy otherwise matriarchy ([1,8]; digital supplementary material, Notice 1). A changeover out of matrilineal in order to patrilineal kinship adopted upon the organization out-of pastoralism additionally the production of alienable assets not as much as male handle , moving on post-marital house activities away from matrilocal to help you patrilocal and carrying out specialized patriliny [seven,17].
During this time period, the reduced regularity away from matriliny mix-culturally, along with high evidence of changes away from matriliny and a good relative lack from facts to possess transitions with the matriliny, were given and removed because the service on unilineal progression model . Ethnographers of the several months saw correlates out of matriliny seen in this other kinship possibilities as the ‘vestiges’ or ‘survivals’ [thirteen,14] out-of a prior matrilineal stage [18,19], and you will seen the fresh world’s extant matrilineal communities because not yet with ‘evolved’ toward later models .
Yet ,, during the early 20th-century, arguments so you’re able to unilineal progression-towards empirical, theoretical and you can ideological grounds-contributed to their refuse because principal make of development within the the fresh public sciences . Boas was first confident of your get across-cultural precedence regarding matriliny, but after desired changes on matriliny as counterexamples so you’re able to ‘discredit Morgan’ and his awesome make of evolution (, p. 71), if you are over the Atlantic, Radcliffe-Brownish plus denied the notion of matrilineal consideration (digital supplementary matter, Note 2). Lowie [24,25] saw brand new group of societies since purely matrilineal or purely patrilineal once the very simplistic as well as odds having ethnographic observations (look for along with ), and you may Malinowski , p. 265) typed that ‘[the] matter comes up should it be anyway needed seriously to create one hypotheses regarding the “basic roots” and you can “successive level” throughout the relying out of descent’ (digital supplementary issue, Notice step 3). States from an early on matrilineal/matriarchal phase off progression ergo presumed ‘a lot more suspicious aspect’ (, p. 84) into the expanding significance of personal ethnographic research (select together with [27,29]).
(ii) Functionalism/architectural functionalism and you will ecological anthropology
To the waning regarding unilineal concepts, anthropologists started to understand the associations typifying matriliny and other descent regulations once the working to suffice the requirements of organizations (architectural functionalism; ) or individuals in this communities (functionalism otherwise private/emotional functionalism; ). Each other Malinowski and you may Radcliffe-Brown refuted the fresh new historical reconstruction of your own unilineal evolutionists additionally the dinner ‘the working contacts between contemporaneous organizations out of a beneficial society’ (, p. xi), trying to see matriliny with their environment, social and you can technological correlates .
(; for additional conversation, find ). Murdock spotted changes regarding matriliny since a reaction to this disorder. Such as and , Murdock discovered matriliny as adversely of male authority, patrilocal/virilocal house and you may ‘[the] intensity of [movable] possessions [or money] in the possession of of men’ (p. 207). That it provided Murdock (p. 207) in order to argue that riches inside the pets, submissives or any other movable property, together with homes (digital additional topic, Notice cuatro), empowered enterprising dudes so you’re able to substitute bride to be provider having brideprice also to ‘[transmit] their residence to their own sons in place of to their sororal nephews’ (find in addition to [thirty-five,36], this dilemma). Combined with warfare and political expansion/integration, movable possessions and additionally enjoy dudes to resist way of living suggesting matrilocal/uxorilocal house ([dos,37,38], get a hold of in addition to ). Murdock noticed so it co-incidence regarding matrilineal kinship and you may patrilocal household as rife sexy Baltican mulheres having ‘interior disharmonies or inconsistencies’ (, p. 135) for example ‘unpredictable and unmistakably transitional’ (, pp. 31–32; ), arguing you to definitely since the patrilocal house proliferate within this a residential area, existing matri-organizations feel geographically dispersed and you can socially functionless (where function is dependent on topography), and you may was in fact browsing possibly changeover to incipient patriliny otherwise (toward death of exogamy) bilateral origin which have patrilocal household [2,29].
Commentaires récents